top of page

The Cheapest Sandwich Ever (Chopped Cheese) | But Cheaper

A bodega Chopped Cheese can be made homemade for even cheaper than you might have imagined. Homemade hero rolls are at the heart of this,...

A bodega Chopped Cheese can be made homemade for even cheaper than you might have imagined. Homemade hero rolls are at the heart of this, but not before paying homage and respect to the humble sandwich. Before you get all nervous we brought a guest to teach us the good ol' fashioned New York way.


Hero Roll:

  • 2.5 teaspoons (8g) instant yeast

  • 302g (302ml) water

  • 600g bread flour

  • 2.5 tablespoons (33g) sugar

  • 2g amylase

  • 2 teaspoons (14g) fine sea salt

  • 1/4 cup (34g) unsalted butter

  • fine cornmeal for dusting

  • 1 egg white

  • 1/2 cup (118ml) water


  • 1.5 lbs Ground beef

  • 4 cloves garlic, finely chopped

  • 10 slices American Cheese

  • 10 slices Swiss cheese

  • 1 sliced sweet onion

  • 4 serrano chilies

  • hero roll, toasted

  • mayo

  • ketchup

  • iceberg lettuce, thinly sliced

  • salt and pepper

  • 3 large tomatoes sliced


Hero Roll:

  1. Preheat oven to 375 F.

  2. In a container mix water (90F) and yeast until dissolved, follow that with sugar, whisk until dissolved, and pour into your stand mixer bowl with the dough hook attachment. In a separate bowl, mix the bread flour and sea salt. Add your flour mix a heaping spoon at a time until all it has been added. Let that mix for five minutes or until your dough turns smooth; then add unsalted softened butter, let that mix for another two minutes or until incorporated and smooth.

  3. Shave your dough into a ball, place it on a greased bowl, cover with plastic wrap, and let it rise for one hour at room temperature or until doubled. Next, degas your dough by punching; divide into eight evenly sized balls, cover them with a damp towel and rest for ten minutes.

  4. Roll your balls into a rectangle (roughly 7” by 4”). Then starting from the long side, roll it tightly into a log, seal the seam, then roll it out to the ends to taper (try not to get it too long); place them onto a baking sheet lightly dusted with cornmeal, and repeat with the rest of the balls. Next, cover them with another baking sheet inverted, wrap it with plastic wrap and let them proof at room temperature for 30 minutes.

  5. Whisk one egg white in water until thoroughly combined, pour that into a spray bottle, and spray your dough to coat evenly and lightly with egg wash. (you can use a brush too). Next, using a sharp razor, score your dough at a 35-degree angle, about a quarter of an inch deep into the dough. Place in the oven and bake for 15 - 2o minutes.

  6. Remove and brush with melted butter (optional), then cool on a wire rack until completely cool.


  1. Split your hero roll, leaving one side attached, toast it lightly on a flat top and increase the heat to medium-high. Next, add a little oil, then a handful of sliced onions and ½ of a thinly sliced serrano pepper, season with salt, and saute until softened and lightly charred, about two to three minutes, and set aside.

  2. Place your ground beef on your flat top, spread the meat out, get a nice sear, let it cook for about two to three minutes, then flip and season with salt.

  3. Chop the meat using the spatula, get it as finely as possible, and let it cook, occasionally stirring. Toss the beef with the veggies back together; line it up roughly into the shape of your bread, add chopped garlic and fold it together until just hot.

  4. Layer on two slices of American cheese and one slice of swiss cheese.

  5. Add a nice layer of mayo to your toasted hero roll, a generous drizzle of ketchup, pepper your buns, place the beef with the melted cheese onto your bread. Next, add some thinly sliced tomato, previously salted, and pepper (let them sit for ten minutes)—finally, some thinly sliced iceberg lettuce.

  6. Tightly wrap it a sandwich paper to serve.

5 comentários

Gerry Phibbs
Gerry Phibbs
20 de dez. de 2021

Daniel -- have a look - it does help improve the texture (softens it) and can sometimes improve the flavor of the bread. (Won't let me post the link!). Check Amazon for "amylase baking - try the 1.5 oz size to start! Good luck!

03 de jan. de 2023
Respondendo a

shut up dweeb


Daniel Schoonover
Daniel Schoonover
20 de dez. de 2021

What is amylase? It isn't a typical ingredient in home kitchens and I want to make sure you aren't talking about malt powder. Also, the hero recipe calls for TWO different water quantifies. So is it 302g of water and 118g of water? I'm assuming one is for the yeast and sugar and the other is just added somewhere during the instructions?

Douglas Haugen
Douglas Haugen
28 de set. de 2023
Respondendo a

The second mention of water is to mis with the egg white to brush the rolls.


Let's Get Cooking

Recent Recipes

bottom of page